complex knee instabilities

Medial

Restraints

·      primary medial stabiliser is MCL

·      primary medial stabiliser at 30o flexion

·      secondary medial stabiliser in extension

·      secondary medial stabilisers are

·      ACL

·      medial capsule with deep medial ligament

·      posterior oblique ligament

·      tertiary medial stabiliser is PCL

Tears

·      MCL usually tears at femoral end

·      stiffness more likely at femoral end

·      laxity more likely at tibial end

associated injuries
Anterior cruciate ligament
Meniscus

·      most common with combined MCL and LCL injury

·      lateral meniscus more commonly injured (3:1)

Classification

·      tested in extension and in 30o flexion

Grade 1

·      I+ laxity in flexion

·      indicates mild sprain of MCL (up to 1/3 torn)

·      usually no laxity in extension

Grade 2

·      2+ laxity in flexion

·      indicates moderate sprain of MCL (1/3 to 2/3 torn)

·      usually no laxity in extension

Grade 3

·      3+ laxity in flexion

·      indicates complete disruption of MCL

·      usually laxity in extension

·      indicates disruption of secondary restraints

·      ACL laxity demonstrated by positive Lachmann’s test

·      posterior oblique ligament instability demonstrated by positive anterior drawer in external rotation

·      PCL laxity demonstrated by positive posterior sag

Clinical features
History

·      direct blow to lateral knee or twisting injury

·      feeling of ripping

·      swelling usually delayed

·      extra-articular

Examination

·      discreet tenderness at femoral or tibial insertion of MCL

·      laxity as above

·      pain on stressing with Grade 1 and 2 injuries

X-ray

·      usually normal in acute injury

·      may be calcification of femoral insertion of MCL

·      Pellegrini-Stieda lesion

·      stress films may be useful

·      MRI usually not required

Treatment
General

·      nonoperative treatment

·      see after injury and treat as below

·      reassess at 2 wks for

·      locked meniscal tear

·      ACL injury

·      arthroscopy indicated for meniscal tear

·      unlock meniscus

·      if no ACL injury, suture meniscus

·      if ACL injury, do not suture at time

·      return at 6-12 wks for meniscal suture and ACL reconstruction

Grade 1

·      control pain and inflammation

·      analgesics

·      ice and elevation

·      splint only in first few days if required

·      weight-bearing

·      as tolerated

·      often need crutches early

·      range-of-movement exercises

·      started early

·      aim to regain full flexion and extension

·      muscle-strengthening exercises

·      started once full ROM achieved

·      quadriceps and hamstring strengthening

·      resumption of activities

·      once strengthening progressed

Grade 2

·      as above plus brace for 2-4 wks

·      use knee immobiliser brace to

·      protect against valgus stress

·      prevent full extension

·      regimen is

·      15o - 90o for 2 weeks

·      0o - 90o for 2 weeks if still painful

Grade 3

·      as above except

·      brace for 4-6 wks

·      add 30o to 60o for 2 weeks initially

·      prevention of extension addresses injury to posterior oblique ligament

Associated ACL injury

·      treat MCL injury nonoperatively as above

·      will reliably heal

·      delayed ACL injury if indicated

·      delay decreases postoperative complications

Associated meniscal injury

·      meniscus should be preserved if possible

·      immediate intervention not required

Locked knee

·      only indication for immediate intervention is locked knee

·      usually noted at early (2 week) reassessment

·      early arthroscopy should be performed

·      if ACL intact, meniscus should be sutured at the time if possible

·      if ACL ruptured, meniscus should be reduced only

·      should return at 12 wks for meniscal suture and ACL reconstruction

Features of tear

·      arthroscopy should be performed if symptoms and signs of meniscal injury

·      should be delayed until patient has recovered from MCL injury

·      tears should be sutured if possible

·      should be combined with ACL reconstruction if ACL ruptured

ACL reconstruction

·      tear may be found at time of reconstruction

·      should be sutured if possible

Lateral

Restraints

·      primary lateral stabiliser is LCL

·      primary lateral stabiliser at 30o flexion

·      secondary lateral stabiliser in extension

·      secondary lateral stabilisers are

·      ITB

·      popliteus and arcuate ligament      

·      ACL

·      tertiary medial stabiliser is PCL

Classification

·      tested in extension and in 30o flexion

·      somewhat theoretical because practically impossible to tear LCL in isolation

·      usually associated posterolateral corner injury

Grade 1

·      I+ laxity in flexion

·      indicates mild sprain of LCL (up to 1/3 torn)

·      usually no laxity in extension

Grade 2

·      2+ laxity in flexion

·      indicates moderate sprain of LCL (1/3 to 2/3 torn)

·      usually no laxity in extension

Grade 3

·      3+ laxity in flexion

·      indicates complete disruption of LCL

·      usually laxity in extension

·      indicates disruption of secondary restraints

·      ACL laxity demonstrated by positive Lachmann’s test

·      posterolateral corner instability demonstrated by positive anterior drawer in internal rotation

·      other tests for posterolateral corner instability

·      varus knee

·      hyperextension and external rotation of tibia when feet lifted by toes

·      increased external rotation of foot with knee at 90o

Clinical features
History

·      twisting injury or direct blow to medial side of knee

·      often hyperextension injury

·      feeling of ripping

·      swelling usually delayed

·      extra-articular

Examination

·      discreet tenderness on lateral side of knee

·      laxity as above

·      pain on stressing with Grade 1 and 2 injuries

·      may be dysfunction of peroneal nerve

X-ray

·      usually normal

·      may be bony avulsion of head of fibula or Gerdy’s tubercle

·      stress films may be useful

Treatment

·      nonoperative treatment for LCL

Isolated LCL injuries

·      as for Grade 1 MCL

Injury to posterolateral corner

Early

·      some evidence to suggest early repair beneficial

·      if diagnosis in doubt

·      EUA and arthroscopy

·      repair of posterolateral corner

·      reattachment with drillholes through tibia

·      brace and rehabilitation

Late

·      may repair posterolateral structures at time of ACL reconstruction

·      if externally rotates > 15o

·      LCL and arcuate ligament identified and bone block from femur raised and advanced proximally with knee in internal rotation

·      if knee in varus with lateral thrust in stance phase, valgus proximal tibial osteotomy required