evaluation of painful THR

General

introduction

·      major complications of THR are

·      infection

·      loosening

·      both cause pain

·      difficult to differentiate

·      no test is 100% specific or sensitive

aetiology

·      pain may be due to causes

·      intrinsic to arthroplasty

·      extrinsic to arthroplasty

Intrinsic

·      infection

·      loosening

·      micromotion (thigh pain in uncemented)

·      heterotopic ossification

·      stress fracture

·      prosthesis failure

Extrinsic

·      muscular

·      irritation of psoas over acetabulum

·      stretching of adductors

·      trochanteric bursitis

·      nonunion of trochanteric osteotomy

·      lumbar pathology

·      spinal stenosis

·      knee pathology

·      degenerative joint disease

classification of infection
Early postoperative

·      acute fulminating infection

·      develops within 1 month of surgery

·      wound infection or infected haematoma that has progressed to deep infection

·      typically

·      febrile patient

·      red swollen discharging wound

Late chronic

·      more indolent

·      develop more than 1 month from surgery

·      typically

·      well patient

·      healed wound

·      worsening of pain

·      never pain-free interval

Acute haematogenous

·      acute onset of clinical symptoms

·      can occur several years after surgery

·      typically

·      well patient

·      previously well functioning hip

Diagnosis

·      history and examination should be able to identify

·      early postoperative infection

·      causes extrinsic to arthroplasty

·      difficulty differentiating

·      late infection

·      aseptic loosening

·      no imaging modality can reliably differentiate them

CLINICAL

·      should be able to

·      identify early postoperative infection

·      differentiate extrinsic from intrinsic causes

History

Pain

·      most common symptom

Nature

·      absence of pain-free interval suggests

·      indolent infection

·      pathology elsewhere (hip or spine)

·      pain-free interval suggests

·      loosening

·      infection

·      implant failure

·      mechanical pain suggests loosening

·      rest pain and night pain suggests infection

Location

·      buttock and groin pain suggests acetabular pathology

·      thigh and knee pain suggests femoral patholog

·      pain over greater trochanter suggests

·      trochanteric bursitis

·      nonunion of trochanteric osteotomy

·      pain in other locations suggests other causes

·      buttock, thigh and calf in spinal stenosis

·      knee and shin in osteoarthritis of knee

·      calf in ischaemic claudication

Drainage

·      next most common symptom

·      strongly suggestive of infection if still present 1 month after operation

Bacteraemia

·      history of bacteraemia suggests infection

Examination

·      pain with hip motion suggests

·      loosening

·      infection

·      implant failure

·      wound induration, erythema and drainage suggests infection

·      examine spine, knee and vascular system

Plain x-ray

·      next step in investigation

·      problems

1.   may be normal in face of pathology in arthroplasty

2.   cannot always differentiate infection and loosening

Infection

·      suggestive features

·      radiolucent lines

·      focal osteolysis with endosteal scalloping

·      periosteal new bone formation *

·      x-rays may be normal in presence of infection

Loosening

·      easier to identify loosening in femur than acetabulum

·      femur  - 90% accuracy

·      acetabulum - 65% accuracy

·      lucent lines do not necessarily represent problem

·      often due to remodelling

·      may be present in well-fixed prosthesis

Definite signs

Stem

·      migration of component

·      cement fracture

·      fracture of stem

Cup

·      migration

·      crack in cement mantle

Probable signs

Stem

·      continuous radiolucent line at bone-cement interface

Cup

·      continuous radiolucent line > 2 mm

Laboratory

·      WCC, ESR and CRP obtained

·      useful markers but not specific for infection

WCC

·      uniformly found to be of little value

·      raised only in fulminant sepsis

ESR

·      widely used

Problems

Variable response to surgery

·      usually slightly increased before surgery

·      variable pattern after surgery

·      may remain elevated for 12 months

May be elevated by concurrent conditions

·      esp. inflammatory arthropathy

Does not differentiate between infection and loosening

·      may be increased with loosening

·      not always increased with infection

CRP

·      less widely used

Advantages

More predictable response to surgery

·      normal before surgery

·      rapid rise with peak 2 days after surgery

·      rapid decrease after 3 days

·      normal by 3 weeks

Helps to differentiate between infection and loosening

·      rarely increased with loosening

·      almost invariably increased with infection

nuclear medicine
Technetium bone scan

·      next step in investigation

Advantages

Sensitive test

·      pathology unlikely if bone scan negative

·      very unlikely if x-rays and bone scan negative

Problems

Variable response after THR

·      increased uptake postoperatively

·      usually return to baseline by 6 months

·      may persist

·      20% at 6 months

·      10% at 12 months

·      but uptake is stable or decreasing

Does not differentiate causes of increased uptake

·      poor specificity

·      increased with

·      infection

·      loosening

·      heterotopic bone formation

·      fracture

·      suggested that

·      diffuse uptake suggestive of infection

·      focal uptake suggestive of loosening

Gallium scan

·      not useful alone

·      used as sequential test

·      with technetium scan

·      infection suggested if

·      uptake incongruent

·      Ga uptake > Tc uptake in same area

Advantages

Sensitive

·      few false positives

·      sensitivity 90%

Disadvantages

Not specific

·      numerous false negatives

·      sensitivity 50%

·      thus has

·      strong positive predictive value

·      weak negative predictive value

Labelled white cell scan

·      initially thought to be superior to sequential Tc-Ga scan

·      later results less promising

·      little place in routine workup

Disadvantages

Ineffective in detecting chronic infections

·      response less granulocytic

Expensive and labour-intensive

·      white cells must be harvested, labelled and re-injected

·      not offered at many centres

aspiration and arthrography
Aspiration

Technique

·      insert needle into pseudocapsule

·      under II control

·      aspirate hip joint

·      if dry tap, inject saline and aspirate again

·      take Trucut biopsy of capsule

Results

·      false-negative may be seen with

·      unsuccessful aspiration

·      concurrent antibiotic administration

·      technical laboratory factors

·      sensitivity reported at 66%

·      false-positive may be seen with contamination of specimen

·      specificity reported at 80-90%

Arthrogram

Technique

·      inject contrast into pseudocapsule

·      inject until patient feels discomfort

·      image with II

Results

·      strongly predictive of loosening with contrast at cement-bone interface

Approach

HISTORY AND EXAMINATION->extrinsic->APPROPRIATE Rx

               \/

               intrinsic

               \/

          PLAIN X-RAY->not loose->BONE SCAN->not hot->OBSERVE

               \/                  \/

                 loose                      hot

            ____     \/____________________\/__

          \/             \/                 \/

          ESR    and      CRP       and     ASPIRATION

            \/             \/                   \/

all positive      some positive    none positive

            \/             \/                \/

            INFECTED                          NOT INFECTED

                     \/                  \/                  \/

       2-stage revision       1-stage revision with biopsy                                      \/

        aspiration positive     OR            aspiration negative

     Hx,Ex,XR,ESR,CRP                       Hx,Ex,XR,ESR,CRP

not suggestive of infection       suggestive of infection

                                      \/

                      REPEAT ASPIRATION

                      \/                \/

                        positive          negative

                      \/                \/

                       INFECTED   NOT INFECTED